Heartache at Gymnastics: U.S.’s Jordyn Wieber Misses Qualifying for All-Around Final

In an upset, world all-around champion Jordyn Wieber doesn't muster enough points to earn one of the US's two spots in the all-around competition

  • Share
  • Read Later
David Eulitt / Kansas City Star / MCT / ZUMA PRESS

Jordyn Wieber of the U.S., center, weeps as she is consoled by Team USA assistant coach Jenny Liang, left, after the scoreboard display of the final team and individual standings in the women's gymnastics preliminaries of the London 2012 Summer Olympic Games on Sunday, July 29, 2012.

It’s going to be an awkward night at the US gymnasts’ dorm in the Olympic Village. How will Aly Raisman and Jordyn Wieber, roommates and good friends, deal with the fact that one is moving on to the all-around competition, the premier event in women’s gymnastics, while the other is not?

Wieber is the world all-around champion and (was) a heavy favorite for the all-around title. Raisman has played the perennial bridesmaid, finishing third at the US Olympic Trials and at the past three national championships. At the previous two Olympics, the US has claimed the gold in the event and was aiming for a three-peat. With Wieber.

But only two gymnasts from each country can qualify for the event, and Wieber finished third among her teammates. Raisman was the top scorer for the US, with Gabrielle Douglas .126 and Wieber .359 points behind.

(MORE: Gabby Douglas: Team USA’s Flip Artist)

“It’s very hard to even grasp this situation,” Nastia Liukin, the reigning Olympic all-around champion, said to NBC. “It’s a shame there’s a rule of only two per country.”

It was a shocker that left the entire team stunned. Trying to register that she wouldn’t be continuing on to compete in the all-around event, in which gymnasts go head-to-head on all four apparatus, Wieber spoke to television media but bypassed the rest of the press, in tears. Later, she issued a written statement in which she said, “It is a bit of a disappointment. It has always been a dream of mine to compete in the all-around final of the Olympics but I’m proud of Aly and Gabby and happy that they reached the all-around and that I was able to help the team get to the finals. It was always going to be close between the three of us doing all-around and in the end it is what it is.”

(MORE: Liang Chow’s Coaching Gymnastics Journey: From Beijing to West Des Moines)

Her coach, John Geddert, was more emotional. “I’m basically devastated for her,” he said, calling the two-gymnasts-per-team restriction “a dumb rule.” “One kid is going to make a mistake that costs her country a medal, and they have to live with that the rest of their life. So the FIG [International Gymnastics Federation] needs to start rethinking some of these things. A kid’s training their entire life and because they’re the third best in their country, they don’t get to go to the dream competition. I don’t know where they’re coming from. She has trained her entire life for this day and to have it turn out anything less than she deserves is going to be devastating. She’ll go into her little shell and it’ll be a while until she comes out.”

What does this do for Team USA? In two days, the team finals crown the leading gymnastics nation, and it’s a title the US wants badly. It’s been 16 years since we claimed team gold—the last time in 1996, in Atlanta, with the memorable vault by a hobbled Kerri Strug. The format is unforgiving – three gymnasts compete on the beam, uneven bars, vault and floor exercise—and all three scores count. (In the qualifying round, four athletes compete and the lowest score can be thrown out.) All three gymnasts need to be on their game, focused on nothing else but their routines. Will the dynamic between Raisman and Wieber taint the balance and the concentration of the team?

(MORE: The Year of the Woman: The London Olympics Strikes Early for Gender Equality)

“It’s really hard of course, because we are best friends, and I know how bad[ly] she wanted it,” says Raisman. “That was one of the first things we said: ‘I felt so bad just because she worked so hard too.’”

Raisman is also the team captain, charged with motivating the team and keeping them from pulling apart during situations like this one. What can she say that will help Wieber and not sound self-serving?

“When this kind of disappointment happens, you can’t say anything,” says Martha Karolyi, national team coordinator. “It’s almost like when somebody passes away—what do you say? Anything you say in that situation is the same. I will try to be comforting and appreciative of her efforts because she definitely had a very strong effort and performed at the highest level she could.”

Known for her consistency and solid performances, Wieber wasn’t as precise as she normally is during competitions. A perfectionist, she had a small break in form on the uneven bars, balance bobbles on the beam, and stepped out of bounds on the floor exercise—a mandatory 0.1 deduction. Douglas tallied up the highest score on uneven bars with her high-flying release moves, but had a few balance bobbles on the beam and stepped out of bounds on floor exercise as well. Raisman was solid throughout, particularly on the beam and floor exercise, her specialties, to earn one of the all-around spots. “The other girls were so strong, and Jordyn wasn’t quite as sharp,” says Karolyi.

(PHOTOS: Interactive Panorama: Inside the Opening Ceremony)

And at this level, even the smallest mistakes can be costly. The new code of points by which judges score gymnasts is unrelenting in rewarding only high difficulty skills that are executed flawlessly. It doesn’t matter that you are a world champion or an Olympian; if your handstand isn’t perfectly vertical on the uneven bars or your vault lands outside the prescribed dismount zone, judges will shave points off your score.

And the stakes will be even higher when teams go up against each other: the qualifying scores are thrown out and the tally starts over, with all scores on the line for the team total. “With the three-up-and-three-count [format], every mistake counts,” says Mihai Brestyan, Raisman’s coach.

Karolyi is hoping that the entire team of five can “turn the page” on today’s results and move on to that next challenge. Going into that event, the US are the leaders, with 181.863 points, just ahead of Russia and 5.226 points ahead of China, who are the reigning team champions. “It’s always important, no matter how hard or painful it is, to finish what you started,” Liukin said to NBC. “This is where the true meaning of being a teammate comes to play. Going into team finals, it will be so important for all five girls to unite and remember their goal.” And try to forget the heartache.

MORE: 50 Olympic Athletes to Watch

8 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Jaxon Oshita
Jaxon Oshita

Women's gymnastics - how does the list of competitors using the 2 per team rules compare to the scoring top 24?

Boy Scout
Boy Scout

If everything had gone as expected, the top 4 qualifiers could had easily been:

1) Jordan

2) Gabby

3) Girl from Russia

4) Aly

Aly would been  left out of the individual race, but it would have been as expected, so no one would have complained.

As it happened, the results were:

1) Girl from Russia

2) Aly  

3) Gabby 

4) Jordan  

Since Jordan was EXPECTED to be competing, being left out with a 4th place finish seems more unfair than if Aly had come in 4th.  I'm not arguing that  this Top Two per County rule is a good one (it's not), just pointing out that the "unfairness" shouldn't be seen as relative to expectations. 

As a note, China, Russia and Great Britain also have three girls placed in the top 24.  So Jordan is one of four girls left out despite  qualifying with their individual performances.

Oneolddude
Oneolddude

They should have all packed their bags and left. The most unfair rule and just proves to show that when stupid people are in charge, stupid rules are created.

TroyT
TroyT

It doesn't matter how many medals an athlete has won previously or whether or not they are a defending champ, everyone has to qualify for the opportunity to compete for what is a finite number of medals. Jordyn Wieber had as much opportunity to get into the all-arounds as the other three girls on her team did. She didn't perform well enough to do so based on the numbers put up by the other girls ON HER TEAM! So now what? Should another girl from another team, who went through all of the qualifiers to get to the Olympics, all of the pain and effort, should she be stripped of an opportunity just because the scores that she posted against HER TEAM, even though lower than JW, were enough to get her in?

JW had her chance, as the reigning world champ she should have been able to beat two out of the three other girls for the right to move on. She didn't....end of story.

Sat
Sat

Why would they leave? They knew the rule when they went there. It has been the rule since the 2004 olympics. 

MACV
MACV

Well, what about Gabby?

HoneyBoom
HoneyBoom

Nothing to speak of as she has performed consistently and was expected to make the all around competition.

Sat
Sat

Did you watch the competition? Gabby's floor routine was a disaster but her beam was her best ever. Not exactly a consistent performance.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,268 other followers